Non-linearity and “Why do I get tension/compression where there should be no tension/compression?”

The most common answer to this question is because non-linear effects (e.g. compression-only supports) are not active in load cases, but are active in load combinations.

As a result, supports or connections that should release in tension/compression will still behave linearly in load case results, leading to seemingly incorrect forces.

Why this happens

In FEM-Design non-linear behaviour can be considered for supports (e.g. uplift), connections and truss members (e.g. tension-only). The analysis types where non-linearity is included are Load combinations, Imperfections and Stability

Figure 1. Analysis types that include non-linear effects.

To enable non-linear effects, select the “NLE” checkbox at Calculations > Analysis > Load combinations > Setup by load combinations.

 

Figure 2. How to activate non-linear effects.

 

Since these non-linearities are not in effect for the results of Load cases, non-linear results must be viewed in Load combinations.

 

Figure 3. Non-linear support ineffective in Load cases (left), so tension is not released. In Load combinations (right), the non-linear behaviour is active and the results match the intended support condition.

J
Joakim is the author of this solution article.

Did you find it helpful? Yes No

Send feedback
Beklager, at vi ikke kunne hjælpe. Hjælp os med at forbedre denne artikel med din feedback.